honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser
Updated at 1:49 a.m., Tuesday, March 18, 2008

Australian WWII battle cruiser finally found

Associated Press

CANBERRA, Australia — The discovery of the wreckage of an Australian warship that sank with 645 men aboard in a fierce World War II battle promises clues to one of the country's most enduring maritime mysteries, authorities said yesterday.

The wreck of battle cruiser HMAS Sydney was discovered off western Australia, Prime Minister Kevin Rudd announced Monday. The Sydney sank on Nov. 19, 1941, after a battle with the German vessel DKM Kormoran in the worst naval disaster in Australia's history.

All 645 sailors aboard the Sydney were lost and its final resting place remained elusive for decades. The Kormoran also sank, but 317 of its 397-member crew survived and rowed lifeboats to the Australian coast, where they were taken prisoner.

The nation has long been incredulous that the pride of its navy could have been lost to a lightly armed German auxiliary cruiser. For years, various alternate theories have abounded — including that a Japanese submarine really sank the Sydney or that the Kormoran's crew machine-gunned Australian survivors.

The chief of the Royal Australian Navy, Vice Admiral Russ Shalders, said Monday that the find would help determine exactly what happened to the Sydney.

"For 66 years, this nation has wondered where the Sydney was and what occurred to her. We've uncovered the first part of that mystery ... the next part of the mystery, of course, is what happened," Shalders told a news conference Monday.

The Sydney was found upright in 8,100 feet of water on Sunday about 500 miles north of Perth, the capital of Western Australia state, Rudd said.

A $3.9 million, government-funded sonar search found the Kormoran a day earlier about 14 miles away from the Sydney, he said.

Calls to find the Sydney had gained intensity in recent years as siblings and widows of crew members have pleaded for answers before they die. The search began two weeks ago and is headed by U.S. shipwreck hunter David Mearns.

Relatives welcomed the find as helping to resolve pain caused by not knowing where their loved ones died, or exactly what happened to them.

"I haven't felt the sense of relief, but I've broken down and cried," Barbara Craill, whose father Walter Freer, a 38-year-old gunner, disappeared aboard the Sydney, told television's Nine Network.

Ted Graham, chairman of the Finding Sydney Foundation, the group carrying out the search, said a remote-controlled submarine would be used to further examine the wreckage found on the sea floor for clues about the battle.

The searchers plan to replace high resolution sonar equipment with cameras this week to take the first pictures of the wrecks.

The mystery of the Sydney has fueled several books over the years. In 1941, as news of the Sydney's loss shocked Australia, many could not believe that Australia's most famous warship had failed to prevail over the poorly armed German auxiliary cruiser, which had been disguised at a Dutch merchant ship before the battle.

Over the years, books and newspapers have speculated that the Sydney approached the German raider thinking that it had surrendered and that the Kormoran then opened fire with the first devastating salvo of the battle.

The German survivors denied this, saying they dropped their disguise and hoisted the German ensign before firing on the Sydney.

Wes Olsen, an Australian author of a book about the Sydney published in 2000, said no one would ever know why the Sydney came within 1,500 meters (1,600 yards) of the raider, well within the range of its guns.

"We are always going to be in the dark as to what prompted the captain of Sydney to go so close to what must have been clear to him a suspicious vessel," Olsen told Australian Broadcasting Corp. radio Monday.

The fact that the only survivors were Germans also cast doubt over eyewitness accounts. The Sydney's radio remained silent throughout the brief and ferocious battle and after.

Australian newspapers have published accusations that the German crew massacred Sydney survivors with machine-gun fire. The Germans who survived steadfastly denied such accusations, which have been never been supported by evidence.

The Germans said they were in life rafts when they last saw the blazing Sydney limping over the horizon toward Perth, lighting the night sky as it burned from bow to stern.

Another popular theory is that the Sydney was sunk by a Japanese submarine a month before Japan officially entered the war by attacking the U.S. Navy at Pearl Harbor, Hawaii. No evidence has been found to support this theory.

A parliamentary inquiry found in 1999 that the Kormoran's underwater torpedo tubes could have been decisive in the Australians' catastrophic loss.

Sonar images of the Sydney wreck supports that theory, said Mearns, the shipwreck hunter who was involved in finding the wrecks of the British battle cruiser the HMS Hood and the DKM Bismarck, the German battleship that sank it in the North Atlantic in 1941.

He said that the wreck was largely intact, but a 80-foot section of the bow had snapped off.

"Our feeling now is that the loss of the bow which had been weakened by the torpedo hit on her port side ... is probably what ... sent Sydney to the seabed," Mearns told ABC.