honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser
Posted on: Monday, January 23, 2006

Lying: Is winning job worth losing reputation?

By Andrea Kay

With all the ruckus about James Frey's memoir, "A Million Little Pieces," and how much of it is fact or fiction, it got me wondering if anyone was nervous about being caught red-handed with a resume they had embellished and turned out to be part fact, part fiction.

Yes, fabricated facts on resumes happen — way too often. And too many creative resume writers don't seem to care that someone will find out they don't have that degree or that they didn't manage a department of 200 people.

If you just look at executives, 10.73 percent of executives lied on their resumes early last year, according to the Liars Index. The Index is a calculation of the percentage of lying executives created by Jude M. Werra of the executive search firm Jude M. Werra & Associates in Brookfield, Wis., says HR Magazine.

Apparently, readers don't seem to care much that some best-selling memoirs have turned out to be partly fabricated. One person posting a message on Oprah Winfrey's Web site said, "Every author embellishes a story, call it what you want," according to an article in The New York Times.

Some workers tell me the same thing about lying on their resumes — that "everybody does it" — and hence, the reason they do it. "It's the only way to compete with other people," one worker told me.

They also don't expect to get caught, saying that too many companies don't check out an applicant's background. But when a company does, your goose is cooked.

Werra tells about a man who claimed to have an executive MBA from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. But MIT said it had no such record.

When he asked the man about it, the man faxed a copy of the diploma — that showed he had completed a program lasting a few weeks. But it wasn't an MBA.

The man's response? "Picky, picky."

Your career may not be as juicy as you'd like. And you may not meet every qualification for a particular job. But making up accomplishments to fit the requirements or gain notice in your field isn't the answer, either.

Look at what happened to Hwang Woo-suk, the South Korean researcher whose claims to have created human embryonic stem cells from patients turned out to be fraudulent. Who will ever take him seriously again?

So first, go after jobs you're qualified for. If you meet most requirements of a position but don't fit the bill perfectly, focus on stating information in your resume, letters and conversations that elaborates on what you do have, and more, than makes up for whatever you lack.

Highlight areas in which you've had noticeable results that carry weight and demonstrate your value. If it's education you're lacking, play up continued education classes that are applicable, even if they didn't result in a degree. I know many people who took coursework but didn't have the degree and got the job offer because they had the confidence to see how right they were for the position and then conveyed that to the employer.

When you're telling your story, take the high road and believe in it with all your heart. You potentially gain more points and don't risk messing with your reputation — which is much harder to regain.

E-mail Andrea Kay at andrea@andreakay.com.